Monday, June 20, 2022

Steele and brass / Skirting the issue / Illegal procedure

Steele and brass. Seeking to establish its own “right to free speech,” ESPN management has filed a motion to dismiss sports anchor Sage Steele’s freedom-of-speech lawsuit against the network, which “sidelined” her with pay after potentially insensitive on-air comments.
Read more on Steele’s original lawsuit here
Sports Illustrated took heat on Twitter after promoting its story on high school football coach Joe Kennedy and his fight to pray on the field by saying a Supreme Court win would be “an erosion” of the separation between church and state.
CBS News tackles the history of the coach’s religious freedom case. 

‘We will never stop.’ Driven by a leaked Supreme Court opinion that would overturn Roe v. Wade, pro-choice protesters staged another residential demonstration, this time outside Justice Amy Coney Barrett’s home.
The Federalist’s John M. Reeves writes that individuals who picket outside Supreme Court justices’ residences should be charged with breaking the law, since attempting to intimidate judges is not allowed under the law.
First Amendment author and professor Lynn Greenky in Ms. ponders this: “If sidewalk counseling regarding options to continue a pregnancy is protected political speech, so too should be counseling options regarding the choice to legally terminate a pregnancy.” 

Like it, love it, want more of it. Despite the criticism and obstacles they face, most journalists would not trade their jobs for anything else, according to a new Pew Research Center poll.
Poynter’s Erin McGroarty examines the societal shift that has moved journalists covering real-time protests from observers to targets and the ramifications for press freedom.

‘We should allow people to say what they want.’ The Guardian says Elon Musk made that comment during a conference call with employees of Twitter—a company he’s pursuing but doesn’t yet own —a session that morphed into a freedom-of-speech address.
HuffPost’s Ryan Grenoble questions how Musk can profess to be a “free speech absolutist” but allow the termination of employees who penned a letter criticizing him for what the company called “overreaching activism.”
Opinion: Andrew Napolitano, author and former New Jersey judge, says Twitter is free to suppress or allow any speech or speaker on its site, “unless it is doing the government’s bidding.” 
With a $4 million bounty on his head and a mantra that “free speech should be seen as the air we breathe: self-evident,” author Salman Rushdie turns 75.

Skirting the issue. After a long legal battle between a charter school and its students, a North Carolina judge ruled that gender-specific uniform requirements are unconstitutional
The University of Houston has settled a lawsuit with a First Amendment rights group that protested a school policy “designed to chill student speech.” 
Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis’ “anti-WOKE” bill faces a new legal challenge as a union representing college faculty members pushes back
North Carolina law enforcement agencies have agreed to a $336,000 settlement stemming from a 2020 peaceful rally where marchers were pepper-sprayed and arrested

Closed doors. A Tennessee federal judge denied an editor’s lawsuit complaining that an annual conference of state judges should be open to the public, ruling that the gathering would not produce any policy decisions
■ An Arizona Supreme Court vice chief justice, ruling against a Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press challenge to have juror names publicly available, says that “providing them … might even imperil jury integrity.”
The Detroit News reports that two Republican gubernatorial hopefuls disqualified from Michigan’s August primary ballot plan to sue the companies that circulated petitions after thousands of signatures were ruled invalid
■ A self-proclaimed “rabbi rouser” is suing the state of Florida over abortion restrictions, claiming they violate religious freedoms of Jewish law.

‘Dark day for press freedom.’ As Wikileaks founder Julian Assange faces the prospect of extradition to the U.S. for espionage charges, Wikileaks defends him as a journalist “being punished for doing his job.”
■ The legal battles to come will pit national security against fundamental press-freedom rights

Remembering raised eyebrows. UT-Knoxville media professor Stuart N. Brotman revisits his role during late comedian George George Carlin’s censorship battle with the FCC in 1973.
 HBO shines a light on Carlin’s career with a four-hour biography streaming now.

Illegal procedure. Coming to the defense of Washington Commanders defensive coordinator Jack Del Rio, who told reporters the storming of the U.S. Capitol was a “dust-up,” law professor Jonathan Turley says the NFL should not “be in the business of fining employees because they take the wrong side of a public controversy.” 
Commanders head coach Ron Rivera tells Sports Illustrated he’s read the First Amendment “over and over” and has a copy in his desk.